Is Iams or Purina Better for Dogs? Comprehensive Comparison

Is Iams or Purina Better for Dogs? Comprehensive Comparison

0 By

In the world of dog food, choosing the right nourishment for your beloved pet is paramount. Today, we explore the offerings of two well-known brands, Purina and IAMS, to answer the question: “Is IAMS or Purina better for dogs?” Both brands have recently made significant strides in improving their products.


Purina, with a storied history dating back to 1894, has always been at the forefront of nutritional research. Their commitment to innovation has led to the creation of hypoallergenic food and a wide range of pet products. In contrast, IAMS, established in 1946, has introduced specialized formulas for different life stages and emphasized the positive impact of fatty acids on a dog’s health.


Veterinarians now increasingly recommend both these brands, recognizing their ongoing improvements. Recent concerns over grain-free foods have prompted a return to Purina and IAMS for their safety and quality. These brands have truly come a long way, establishing themselves as reputable choices in the dog food market.

Purina, a renowned name in the world of pet food, has a rich history dating back to its establishment in 1894. Since then, it has come a long way, evolving its products and making significant contributions to pet nutrition.


One of Purina’s defining characteristics is its unwavering commitment to nutrition research. Over the years, the company has invested time and resources in understanding the intricate dietary needs of pets. This research isn’t just an intellectual exercise; it has a direct impact on the health and well-being of dogs. Purina’s dedication to science-backed nutrition has helped shape the way we feed our furry friends, ensuring they receive the best care possible.


One milestone in Purina’s journey was the introduction of hypoallergenic dog food. This innovation was a game-changer for dogs with food sensitivities and allergies. Purina’s hypoallergenic food isolated allergens, making it safe for dogs with dietary restrictions to enjoy a nutritious meal without any adverse reactions. This groundbreaking approach has improved the lives of countless dogs with dietary challenges.


As the years passed, Purina didn’t just focus on quality but expanded its reach globally. The company’s reputation for providing top-notch pet food made it a trusted choice worldwide. In 2001, Nestle acquired Purina, further solidifying its position as one of the largest and most reputable dog food companies in the world. This global recognition reflects Purina’s dedication to delivering excellence in pet nutrition.


Best Sellers at Purina


Best-selling dog foods from Purina cover a wide range of dietary requirements. The most popular options are as follows;


1. Purina One Smart Blend – Chicken and Rice


Purina’s Smart Blend with Chicken and Rice is a hit among adult dogs without specific dietary restrictions. The primary ingredient is chicken, which not only offers a delicious taste but also natural source of glucosamine for healthy joints. This formula is packed with antioxidants to boost your dog’s immune system, helping them stay fit and energetic. Plus, it includes a blend of rice, wheat, and corn, providing essential carbohydrates for energy.


2. Purina Pro Plan Focus – Sensitive Skin and Stomach


If your dog has sensitive skin and stomach, the Pro Plan Focus line is the way to go. This dog food is designed to enhance skin health, thanks to its richness in fatty acids. It’s also fortified with prebiotics to maintain a healthy digestive system. Although this food contains grains, it’s not hypoallergenic, so it’s not meant for dogs with allergies.


3. Purina Pro Plan SAVOR – Shredded Blend with Chicken and Rice


This highly digestible dog food is well-loved for its prebiotics and probiotics, which promote excellent digestive health. It combines the goodness of dry kibble and shredded soft dog food, creating a delightful texture that your dog will adore. Just like other Purina offerings, it’s not tailored for grain-free diets.


Purina’s top-selling dog food products are designed to cater to various needs, ensuring there’s something for every dog. Whether you have an adult dog without dietary restrictions, a dog with sensitive skin and stomach, or a furry friend who appreciates textured meals, these products prioritize essential nutrients to keep your dog healthy and content.


IAMS: A Journey Through History


IAMS, a well-known brand of pet food, has a rich history dating back to its founding in 1946 by Paul IAMS. This brand has played a significant role in the evolution of dog food.

One of the notable contributions of IAMS to the pet food industry was the introduction of life stage dog formulas. These formulas are specially designed to cater to the unique nutritional needs of dogs at different stages of life. Whether it’s a growing puppy or a senior dog, IAMS aimed to provide tailored nutrition for each life stage.


Another pivotal aspect of IAMS’ journey was its research on the benefits of fatty acids for dogs. The company conducted studies that highlighted the positive effects of fatty acids on a dog’s skin and coat. This research led to the development of dog food products enriched with these essential nutrients, promoting better overall health for dogs.


IAMS’ path also witnessed changes in ownership over the years. In 1999, Procter and Gamble acquired IAMS, expressing their intention to expand the brand globally. Later, in 2014, IAMS found a new home under the ownership of MARS, which is recognized as the largest dog food company globally. These transitions in ownership marked significant moments in IAMS’ history, shaping its journey in the pet food industry.


IAMS’ Best Sellers


1. IAMS Proactive Health Adult – Chicken MiniChunks


IAMS Proactive Health Adult with Chicken MiniChunks is a well-rounded dog food suitable for adult dogs. Its primary ingredient is real chicken, ensuring a high-quality source of protein. The formula also contains corn and whole grain sorghum to provide essential carbohydrates. Dried beet pulp is included to support digestion and promote good gastrointestinal health. This dog food is enriched with prebiotics, which contribute to a healthy digestive system. It offers a balanced diet with additional nutrients and vitamins to maintain overall well-being.


2. IAMS Proactive Health – Large Breed with Chicken


Specifically formulated for large breed dogs, IAMS Proactive Health – Large Breed with Chicken features farm-raised chicken as its main ingredient. This provides a rich source of protein while supporting the overall health of large breed dogs. The inclusion of chicken and chicken fat offers glucosamine and chondroitin, which are crucial for promoting joint health. The food is tailored to meet the unique dietary needs of large breeds, offering essential nutrients and vitamins for their well-being.


3. IAMS Proactive Health Smart Puppy – Large Breed


IAMS Proactive Health Smart Puppy – Large Breed is designed to cater to the needs of large breed puppies during their crucial growth and development stages. The formula includes Omega-3 DHA, which plays a key role in brain development. Enriched with 22 nutrients found in a mother dog’s milk, this food ensures that large breed puppies receive the best care in their early life stages. It is specifically created to help large breed puppies grow at a proper pace and stay healthy.


Recall History of Purina and IAMS Dog Food


In the past, both Purina and IAMS have experienced recalls, albeit the frequency and causes have varied.

Purina’s Past Product Recalls


Purina experienced one dog food recall in the last ten years. In August of 2013, there was only one recall.
The product in question, Purina ONE Beyond, was recalled because Salmonella contamination was suspected. Salmonella is a bacteria that can infect both canines and people, leading to food poisoning.


IAMS Product Recalls


In the last ten years, IAMS has had two recalls. Aflatoxin poisoning resulted to the first recall in December 2011, when IAMS ProActive Health Smart Puppy was pulled from shelves. Dogs can be poisoned by aflatoxin, a toxin naturally produced by some molds.
In August of 2013, IAMS recalled six varieties of dry dog food due to a potential health hazard. Salmonella contamination fears prompted this recall.

In order to protect pets from potential harm and keep them healthy, recalls in the pet food sector are crucial. While recalls have happened with both Purina and IAMS, it’s important to keep in mind that these companies manufacture so much pet food that recalls happen rarely.


Considerations When Choosing Dog Food


There are several aspects to think about while selecting the best dog food. Before everything else, think about your dog’s individual health needs. Picking the right dog food is essential if your dog has specific dietary requirements due to allergies, digestive problems, or other health conditions.


Your dog’s activity level is also important. Working dogs and high-energy dogs need diets with more protein and calories to fuel their active lifestyles. Less active dogs, on the other hand, would perform well on a diet designed for their reduced energy needs.


There is a disparity between the dietary needs of toy and large breed dogs due to their size. Smaller kibble may be easier for puppies to chew and digest, whereas larger kibble may be necessary for larger dogs.


Purina vs. IAMS: Key Comparison Factors


Ingredients Chicken primary ingredient

Contains grains

Few superfoods

Chicken primary ingredient

Contains grains

Abundance of superfoods

PriceSlightly more expensiveSlightly cheaper
AvailabilityAvailable in many stores, including grocery stores and boutiquesAvailable in many places but less extensive coverage
VarietiesOffers a wide range of dog food options, 96 unique recipesProvides 21 different dog foods with various categories
TasteDogs may have varying preferencesGenerally preferred by many dogs
Community SupportDonates to Rescue Bank and supports various animal-related causesSupports community initiatives but to a lesser extent


Final Words Is Iams or Purina Better for Dogs


When deciding between IAMS or Purina for your canine companion, it’s essential to consider the specific needs of your dog. Both IAMS and Purina have evolved to provide high-quality pet nutrition, surprising many with their improvements over the years. With minimal recall history and a commitment to pet well-being, these brands are trustworthy choices.

So, whether you’re wondering, “Is IAMS or Purina better for dogs?” the answer lies in the unique requirements of your furry friend. Evaluate factors like your dog’s age, breed, size, and health to choose the most suitable food. Ultimately, both brands offer reliable options for specialty dog food, ensuring your pet receives the nutrition they deserve.

Spread the love